Testimony sent to the Senate Education, Health and Environment Affairs Committee
February 8, 2018
The Montgomery County Taxpayers League supports SB 302 – but with major reservations. The premise of the bill makes eminent good sense – the establishment of an Investigator General (IG) at the state level. No such investigatory body exists at present and oversight suffers. However, there are some problems with the bill.
- We do not see the need – nor the expense – of setting up a whole new commission with all its trappings to select the IG and to whom the IG will report. We have a State Board of Education that could very well fill that role. The Educational Monitoring Unit could be housed either in the Maryland State Department of Education or could be situated within the State Board with the investigative and analytical functions listed in the bill.
- Other than sub poena powers, we are not sure as to why many of the other functions are not currently being performed by the MSDE or through the oversight of the State Board.
- How will the functions of this new entity comport with those of the various boards of education in the state who currently perform many of the same functions. Will IG decisions over-ride personnel decisions protected by local collective bargaining agreements? Will corrective actions mandated by the IG be funded by the state?
- Will it benefit the Investigator General to support the establishment of inspectors general in the larger school districts? Should local jurisdictions elect to do so, will the state fund the establishment of these positions?
It appears to us that the premise of the bill is worthwhile; the creation of yet another free-floating commission is not. The tightening of oversight is worthwhile; the overreach in some of the functions is not. And lastly, though the bill does not intimate it, the establishment of inspectors general in some school systems would strengthen local oversight – and lighten the work load of the proposed Investigator General.
Joan Fidler, President
Montgomery County Taxpayers League